one half of season 4 - I thought this would show all of season 4. Not just the end. I wanted from beginning to end on both season 1 with kelly and season 4 with carrie. thanks. So if any one just wants to see the end than this is for u.
Clay Aiken s Performance Alone Was Worth $$ - This is a great DVD that showcases the best talent of all the seasons. However, Clay Aiken s performance of Bridge Over Troubled Water made this DVD worth every penny. I encourage all Idol lovers to buy this! It s great!
Not the best - Being a very big fan of american idol and watching the show since the first season, I was excited to see they had a video out with the best of American Idol. Well, this was definately not the very best. The clips of the performances are short. There s more talking than anything else. Save your money and watch channel 11 American Idol Rewind.
American Idol, Best of - The extras portion of this video would not play. It was returned for another which was also defective. The main program was OK.
Disappointing - I bought this awhile ago but only watched a little bit. Tonight I watched it in full and have to say that the worst thing about it is that it was so poorly produced. The sound doesn t track to the video properly in much of the DVD. The sound levels are also all over the place in the audition parts. A big fat ZERO to whomever was the sound editor of this DVD and the producer who didn t catch the problem before it was released. This video has one really big redeeming quality that makes it an absolute must for American Idol fans - the entire performance of Bo Bice singing In A Dream a cappella. It was probably one of the most BRILLIANT moments the show will ever have and this is the only place to get it! Fortunately, this song does track properly. I do agree with other reviewers that there were some really stand out moments that were left out. Seriously, with the money this show has made they could afford to put together a well produced DVD for each season separately and not leave out many of the best bits.